I never ever saw a Moor —I never saw the Sea —Yet recognize I how the heath looksAnd what a Billow be.

You are watching: I never saw a moor analysis

I never spoke with GodNor saw in heaven —Yet details am ns of the spotAs if the check were provided —

Comment:

On the surface, a straightforward statement that faith. There are plenty of things ns mean; ns take because that granted I can mean them. God is among things.

As always, the devil is in the details. The first stanza presents two analogies. No a moor (a marshland) no one the sea has actually been seen. Despite a lack of direct experience, in both instances it is recognized how facets of lock look. The moor has heather, which room purple flowers. The sea is created of billows.

The very first stanza actually raises the question of “common sense” in a particular way. We usage words to signify wholes that specify our experience. We room not the the moor, nor of the sea. It sound strange come talk favor this, together it feels favor one has actually no idea what was simply said. Wholes depend on components of which we carry out have much more specific knowledge. However, there room at least two problems with the means the city depicts those parts. First, the isn’t clear the speaker has experience through either heather or billows. Second, the understanding transmitted is the of nature. The second stanza developments supernatural claims:

I never ever spoke through GodNor checked out in sky —Yet particular am i of the spotAs if the check were given —

Initially, that looks choose there will certainly be 2 analogies paralleling the previous stanza. Yet stating the one has neither spoken with God nor saw in sky does no produce any type of further reasoning. Instead, it yields to certainty the a place to which one has actually a ticket (“checks” to be a indigenous popularly used for rail tickets). Before, what seemed to it is in proclaimed expertise of a whole demanded some sort of bookkeeping of that parts.

However, Dickinson’s speak never asserted to recognize a moor or the sea! This poem doesn’t minimize to a straightforward statement the theism or atheism. What that does rather is force the question of what the components of the kingdom that God space on Earth. One could say the answers that inquiry cynically: fatality is a pretty details “spot” because that which we have tickets. Still, the very first two currently of the second stanza are specific about something. Speak to God or visiting in Heaven could reinforce she certainty about that “spot,” every little thing it is.

See more: Of Mice And Men: How Do George And Lennie Know Each Other Men

The funny point is how our preoccupation with fatality makes the mythic central and in one ironic way certain. To recapitulate the poem’s theme: we typical at the very least two points by belief. First, there’s id in regards to the knowledge which human beings gather and also preserve and also give to each other. Our common experience pertains to us v conventionality; us possess photo of nature. Then, there’s belief in terms of the danger we take because that the sake of the divine. Learning we will die, us hope and also pray come be saved by what is supernatural. Benardete when said that belief and also knowledge room of various orders, and I think this is an illustration the what the means. This small poem keeps thinking by analogy minimal to the natural civilization while proceeding a mock ontological proof (the certainty that God is dependency on the most specific thing the will take place to me). Belief and also knowledge talk previous each other, yet as venturers, us engage, use, and want to have both.